Conflict of interest
This project is authored by Ryan Pepple, who owns CalmGut (operating as
SHUVEN, shuven.co), a gut-brain axis supplement
brand. CalmGut/SHUVEN products compete directly with several products
scored in this report. The brand is named and linked here so a reader can
see for themselves what the author sells; the link appears on this page
only, and carries rel="nofollow" so it passes no ranking signal to a
site the author controls.
The author also runs Abovance (abovance.com), an
AI search consultancy that cites this project as its own research.
Abovance does not score products, and as of October 2026 no Abovance
client sells a product in the category scored here. The site credit in
this site's footer links to Abovance with rel="nofollow" for the same
reason.
The author also co-owns Liv Pure, a storefront selling research-use-only peptides and related compounds, including capsule and liquid products. They are not labeled or sold as dietary supplements, and none of them is in this audit's sample, appendix or off-sample file.
Mitigations:
- The rubric was written and committed to version control before any product data was collected. The commit history in this repository is the record.
- No criterion rewards any attribute specific to the author's own products.
- Products in which the author has a commercial interest are excluded from
the ranking and scored separately in an appendix, using the identical
rubric. The appendix is a physically separate file
(
appendix-scores.csv, andappendix-*.csvfor the full run) sharing the ranked file's header, so no ranking, mean, or count computed over the ranked data can include an author-owned product without a deliberate choice to combine the two files.
Appendix: the author’s own products
Author-owned products on file: SHUVEN Reset — Not scored: no current live production label. SHUVEN Reset has no sellable/live product as of 2026-09-22 -- product pages are in draft, launch gated on trademark resolution. Per methodology, only products with a current live label are scored.
When scored, they will be shown here by the identical rubric, never in the ranked results.